Series: Educational Innovations Series
Paperback: 216 pages
Publisher: Harvard Education Press (June 1, 2016)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 1612509126
ISBN-13: 978-1612509129
Product Dimensions: 9 x 6 x 0.4 inches
Shipping Weight: 10.4 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 4.8 out of 5 stars See all reviews (5 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #60,407 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #42 in Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Social Sciences > Philanthropy & Charity #51 in Books > Business & Money > Small Business & Entrepreneurship > Nonprofit Organizations & Charities #109 in Books > Education & Teaching > Schools & Teaching > Education Theory > Reform & Policy
The highest praise for a book is: "it made me think." This one certainly was stimulating and insightful. The provided history is fascinating, as are her model of the two different kinds of foundations, and her analysis of the big four philanthropic funders of public education reform and how their values and strategies differ and converge. She conveys a clear sense of the Gates, Broad, Ford and Kellogg foundations through the many excerpted interviews. By the end of the book each reader is likely to have a favorite - perhaps different from anticipated. I came away with a clear understanding that there may be inherent tension in the idea of private funders acting to create public policy without an elected mandate to do so. But I am nonetheless grateful that in a political, electoral culture that is currently gridlocked, there are generous private foundations experimenting with different strategies to improve a core institution in our democracy: K-12 education.
With Policy Patrons, Megan Tompkins-Stange delivers a thorough, thoughtful, and fair analysis of these foundations' approaches to philanthropy and policy in education. While the book will be useful for anyone in education who has a close-up view of the approach of these foundations (and others like them), anyone interested in policymaking, democracy, and education will likely find this book to be interesting and thought-provoking. A worthwhile read, and a great discussion-starter!
Revealing analysis of philanthropy in education. The author interviewed officials at Gates, Broad, Kellogg, and Ford. Fascinating to hear inside perspective showing how foundation officials describe their work and involvement in policy. Must read for people in philanthropy, ed reform, and policy.
The author develops a useful framework for categorizing foundations' work. The historical background and insider perspectives are interesting. One gets a sense that there is regression toward a more common, slightly shifted perspective on grant-making. A stronger conclusion would have strengthened the argument.
Great inside view of four big foundations (Gates, Ford, Broad, and Kellogg) and how they have shaped education policy over the past decades. It’s interesting just how different their approaches have been, how these have evolved, and some of the tradeoffs of the different approaches. Though this wasn’t the book’s main aim, I also learned a lot from the concise overview of the major education reforms in the U.S. over the past few decades. Really thoughtful and accessible analysis for anyone interested in education policy, philanthropy, or civil society.
Policy Patrons: Philanthropy, Education Reform, and the Politics of Influence (Educational Innovations Series) The Politics of Automobile Insurance Reform: Ideas, Institutions, and Public Policy in North America (American Government and Public Policy) Policy and Politics in Nursing and Healthcare - Revised Reprint, 6e (Mason, Policy and Politics in Nursing and Health Care) Health Policy And Politics: A Nurse's Guide (Milstead, Health Policy and Politics) Energy Policy in the U.S.: Politics, Challenges, and Prospects for Change (Public Administration and Public Policy) Modern Education Finance and Policy (Peabody College Education Leadership Series) Sound Innovations for String Orchestra -- Sound Development (Advanced): Warm-up Exercises for Tone and Technique for Advanced String Orchestra (Viola) (Sound Innovations Series for Strings) Sound Innovations for String Orchestra: Sound Development (Intermediate) for Cello: Warm up Exercises for Tone and Technique for Intermediate String Orchestra (Sound Innovations Series for Strings) Sound Innovations for String Orchestra: Sound Development (Intermediate) for Viola: Warm up Exercises for Tone and Technique for Intermediate String Orchestra (Sound Innovations Series for Strings) Sound Innovations for String Orchestra, Bk 1: A Revolutionary Method for Beginning Musicians (Violin), Book, CD & DVD (Sound Innovations Series for Strings) Sound Innovations for Concert Band, Bk 1: A Revolutionary Method for Beginning Musicians (Flute), Book, CD & DVD (Sound Innovations Series for Band) Sound Innovations for Concert Band, Bk 1: A Revolutionary Method for Beginning Musicians (Trombone), Book, CD & DVD (Sound Innovations Series for Band) Sound Innovations for Concert Band, Bk 1: A Revolutionary Method for Beginning Musicians (B-flat Trumpet), Book, CD & DVD (Sound Innovations Series for Band) Sound Innovations for Concert Band -- Ensemble Development for Intermediate Concert Band: B-flat Trumpet 1 (Sound Innovations Series for Band) Sound Innovations for Concert Band, Bk 2: A Revolutionary Method for Early-Intermediate Musicians (B-flat Trumpet), Book, CD & DVD (Sound Innovations Series for Band) Sound Innovations for Concert Band -- Ensemble Development for Intermediate Concert Band: B-flat Trumpet 2 (Sound Innovations Series for Band) Sound Innovations for String Orchestra, Bk 1: A Revolutionary Method for Beginning Musicians (Cello), Book, CD & DVD (Sound Innovations Series for Strings) Sound Innovations for Concert Band, Bk 2: A Revolutionary Method for Early-Intermediate Musicians (E-flat Alto Saxophone), Book, CD & DVD (Sound Innovations Series for Band) Sound Innovations for Concert Band -- Ensemble Development for Intermediate Concert Band: E-flat Alto Saxophone 1 (Sound Innovations Series for Band) Sound Innovations for Concert Band -- Ensemble Development for Intermediate Concert Band: B-flat Tenor Saxophone (Sound Innovations Series for Band)