Audio CD: 1 pages
Publisher: BBC Audiobooks America; Audio Theater edition (October 8, 2008)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 1602834784
ISBN-13: 978-1602834781
Product Dimensions: 6.2 x 5.4 x 1 inches
Shipping Weight: 4.8 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 4.4 out of 5 stars See all reviews (137 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #1,787,688 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #20 in Books > Books on CD > Authors, A-Z > ( T ) > Tolkien, J.R.R. #1004 in Books > Books on CD > Science Fiction & Fantasy > Science Fiction #1170 in Books > Books on CD > Science Fiction & Fantasy > Fantasy
Is this collection worth purchasing?Tom Shippey's introduction is, as always, incisive and insightful, packed with quotable phrases and interesting observations placing these shorter pieces within Tolkien's oeuvre. But it is aimed at the new reader of these works - it is a guide to how to read them, not ground-breaking new scholarship.I am personally not a fan of realism in illustration of Tolkien's works; I find that a more stylized approach better suits the atmosphere of his writing. This is perhaps purely a matter of personal taste, but I can't read the stories included in this collection without a deep longing for the original illustrations by Pauline Baynes - particularly for Farmer Giles, where Tolkien himself said he felt her artwork reduced his text to a commentary on the drawings. To my mind, Lee's pale, washed-out pencil drawings hardly hold a candle to Baynes' ability to convey the humor, enchantment, and melancholy of Tolkien's shorter works.All of the included works by Tolkien are readily available elsewhere. Roverandom, Farmer Giles, Smith, and On Fairy-stories have recently appeared in excellent stand-alone editions with critical commentary and, when applicable, the original illustrations by Baynes or Tolkien himself. All but Roverandom and Smith are included in The Tolkien Reader, which is still in print, though alas only in paperback; I imagine this collection is meant to replace it in hardback.If you are a fan of Alan Lee, the answer may be yes, though for most of the tales there are actually only two drawings each.
Tales from the Perilous Realm (Four BBC Radio Full Cast Dramas) Sherlock Holmes Essentials, Volume 1 (Six Full Cast BBC Radio Dramas) (BBC Radio Series) Romeo and Juliet: A BBC Radio 3 Full-cast Dramatisation. Starring Douglas Henshall & Cast (BBC Radio Shakespeare) The Complete Miss Marple Radio Dramas (Twelve BBC Radio Dramas Starring June Whitfield) Shakespeare: The Essential Comedies, Volume 1 (Four BBC Radio Full Cast Dramas) The Jane Austen BBC Radio Drama Collection: Six BBC Radio Full-Cast Dramatisations Murder On The Orient Express: A BBC Radio 4 Full-Cast Dramatisation (BBC Radio Collection) Raymond Chandler: The BBC Radio Drama Collection: 8 BBC Radio 4 Full-Cast Dramatisations Bonecrack: BBC Radio 4 Full-cast Dramatisation (BBC Radio Collection) The Secret Pilgrim (BBC Full Cast Radio Drama)(George Smiley series) (BBC Radio Series) The Honourable Schoolboy: A BBC Full-Cast Radio Drama (BBC Radio Series) A Small Town in Germany: A BBC Full-Cast Radio Drama (BBC Radio) Smiley's People: A BBC Full-Cast Radio Drama (BBC Radio Series) Miss Marple's Final Cases: Three new BBC Radio 4 full-cast dramas Agatha Christie: The Lost Plays: Three BBC Radio Full-Cast Dramas: Butter in a Lordly Dish, Murder in the Mews & Personal Call Sherlock Holmes Essentials, Volume 2 (Six Full Cast BBC Radio Dramas) After the Funeral: A BBC Full-Cast Radio Drama (BBC Audio Crime) The Adventure of the Christmas Pudding (A Hercule Poirot Mystery)(BBC Radio Full Cast Drama) (BBC Audio Crime) 4:50 from Paddington: A BBC Full-Cast Radio Drama (BBC Audio Crime) The ABC Murders: A BBC Full-Cast Radio Drama (BBC Audio Crime)