Audio CD
Publisher: Random House Audio; Unabridged edition (December 26, 2007)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0739357581
ISBN-13: 978-0739357583
Product Dimensions: 5.1 x 1.2 x 6 inches
Shipping Weight: 2.7 pounds
Average Customer Review: 3.6 out of 5 stars See all reviews (325 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #2,415,803 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #35 in Books > Books on CD > Authors, A-Z > ( G ) > Garwood, Julie #2153 in Books > Books on CD > Romance #3366 in Books > Romance > Historical > Medieval
Wow, I'd like an Alka Seltzer and a refund, not necessarily in that order. What a huge disappointment, and a hardcover disappointment at that.Others have covered the plot particulars ad nauseum, and since they weren't worth discussing even once, I won't repeat them. Instead, I'll say this:IF Julie Garwood indeed wrote this book, is it really the best she thinks her fans deserve? Her strengths in the past have included strong, likeable heroes and heroines, quirky but believable, who fit her historical style to a "T". Even the repetitive storylines (hard to avoid in romance) worked, because of the characters and her ability to make us root for them. And many of her stories were first-rate as well. Her earlier historicals are among my favorites, especially The Secret, The Wedding, The Prize, The Bride and of course, Honour's Splendor.At some point, Ms. Garwood turned to writing "modern" romance; those books (yes, I actually bought one new based stricly on her name, then another used) were mediocre at best. The snap and vitality of her historical characters just didn't translate to modern times to make those works anything special. At least, not for me.And now, after all these years, apparently Ms. Garwood has decided to settle for being a mediocre (at best) historical romance novelist as well. I know the "modern" romances didn't do as well (that happens when the work doesn't shine). But really....she just phoned this one in. It doesn't sound like her, doesn't work at any level, and has just become for me an expensive doorstop.I've complained in earlier reviews of the dreck pumped out this year by so-called "established" historical romance writers; I was counting on Ms.
The biggest issue I have with this book is that the voice in this book is not the Julie Garwood of THE PRIZE, SAVING GRACE, THE SECRET ect. I realize it has been a long time since we have had a historical offering from Ms Garwood, and that historical romances have evolved into well researched history as well as character driven stories, but Ms Garwood's voice has disappeared, Gone is the quirky funny heroine and the stern but lovable hero who is leveled by the love he feels for his heroine and her antics- typical Garwood "historical light", where the history is a subtle backdrop with characters who drive the romance.Colm and Gabrielle, who don't even come together until after page 100, appear one dImensional: she hardly needs him as she is so perfect (Scottish Gaelic, not the language of King Wm's Scottish court, would hardly be a language she would have learned, at least in a previous book she had Jamie learn it from a native speaker adding a spark to the humor of the story) Garwood missed a chance for misunderstanding by having her heroine so perfect, hardly a reflection of real women of the period royal or not. And he is over shadowed by his brother who would have made a better hero. The inaccurate history takes the knowledgeable reader right out of the story in the beginning and could have been avoided as the elements/characters from other books could have been used as the devise to plot the story into the highlands. No fan expects indepth history from a Garwood novel but we do expect the scenarios to at least be believable and this one was flawed from the beginning and so out of character reflecting Ms Garwood's talent to weave a satisfying tale.Sadly, the story so long anticipated by Garwood fans fell far short of her previous hardcovers and mass market fiction.
Shadow Music is the back-story of the feud between the MacKenna's and the Buchanan's that was discovered in her contemporary novel Shadow Dance: A Novel.Princess Gabrielle's mother was part of the royal family of the Island of St. Biel, before she moved to England to be with her baron husband. The late king of that island was clever and when the Crusaders came he outwitted them, collected tolls, and sent gold to appease the Pope. Since that time rumors have existed about whether or not the king held back some of that gold.Gabrielle is a great beauty and her physical allure is the cause of a competitive feud between two barons. The two baron's, fueled by empty promises by King John that one of the barons will have her hand in marriage, become obsessed with Gabrielle. When King John dupes the barons and promises Gabrielle to a Scottish Laird, the two baron's become more and more devious in their plans for Gabrielle.Gabrielle accepts her fate and travels to Scotland only to have her life turned upside down, yet again. Needing protection she takes shelter with the Laird MacHugh and begins a journey of another sort.I absolutely loved the first half of this story and flipped through the pages rapidly as I got caught up in the characters and intrigue. The romance between the Laird and Gabrielle promised to be explosive and the mystery of the gold and the devious barons added intrigue and excitement. The middle of this book was also great, though it began to plateau a bit. I began to wonder when things were going to start happening.
Shadow Puppets & Shadow Play Eye Shadow Techniques: Amazing and good looking eye shadow techniques for every kind of eye shapes. Ender's Shadow (The Shadow Series) Shadow of the Hegemon (The Shadow Series) Shadow Puppets (The Shadow Series) Shadow of the Giant (The Shadow Series) The Shadow of Death - Book 2 (The Shadow of Death Serial (Amish Faith Through Fire)) Shadow Music: A Novel Valley of the Shadow: A Novel Queen of Fire: A Raven's Shadow Novel, Book 3 Worlds of Ink and Shadow: A Novel of the Brontës Midnight Hour: A Shadow Falls Novel Chosen at Nightfall (A Shadow Falls Novel) Shadow of Power: A Paul Madriani Novel Shadow Woman: A Novel Shadow Kiss: A Vampire Academy Novel Shadow Music Hollow City: The Graphic Novel: The Second Novel of Miss Peregrine's Peculiar Children (Miss Peregrine's Peculiar Children: The Graphic Novel) Clothes, Clothes, Clothes. Music, Music, Music. Boys, Boys, Boys.: A Memoir MUSIC CITY NEWS magazine March 1980 George Jones on cover (The Sound of a City Heard Around The World, Volume XVII No. 9, Country Music, Bluegrass Music,)