Audio CD
Publisher: Random House Audio; Unabridged edition (April 19, 2016)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0307736644
ISBN-13: 978-0307736642
Product Dimensions: 5.2 x 1.1 x 5.9 inches
Shipping Weight: 9.6 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 3.7 out of 5 stars See all reviews (1,011 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #579,442 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #363 in Books > Books on CD > Romance #468 in Books > Literature & Fiction > Women's Fiction > Sisters #1876 in Books > Books on CD > Literature & Fiction > General
Charles Caleb Colton (an English writer who I believe was born in the 1700’s ) once said that: “Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.”Most days I agree with this statement. Today I do not.My shelves are filled with classic literature, and subsequently hundreds of books that retell those classic stories from many different angles in many different eras. They are some of my most beloved books. Why? Because they take what I love and allow me to read it over and over again with fresh eyes.Some of them are silly, most…serious but I have enjoyed each and every one of them for what they are.Until now.When I first caught wind that Curtis Sittenfeld (an author I had not read but heard much about) was publishing a modern retelling of (easily) my favorite book…I was excited. That excitement however, quickly faded when I realized “Eligible” was more of a mockery of Austen’s work than an actual reworking of it.Let’s start with the plot first (because I’m much less angsty about it than the characters.)While the parallels between Austen and Sittenfeld’s version were easily recognizable, most were poorly executed. Not once, but in every chapter scenes were chopped and pieced back together like a puzzle. Insignificant information (usually flashbacks explaining a siblings past behavior, but also the listing of every street name Liz passed during her daily jog) seemed to be Sittenfeld’s niche, engulfing more space than necessary. Because of this quirk…the active plot felt like an afterthought, a stitch in Sittenfeld’s side that needed to be taken care of rather than nurtured. It also led to missed opportunities and bad choices.Most of those bad choices had to do with her characters, and how each was dealt with.
Jane Austen does not seem the type to flip the bird to another lady, but for Curtis Sittenfeld she just might make an exception. Eligible,"a modern retelling" of Pride and Prejudice is worse than dull. Sittenfeld's "homage" completely misunderstands the moral underpinnings and paradox of the original, particularly the character of Elizabeth Bennett, The result is a bloated and banal travesty that proves a cheap imitation is never the sincerest form of flattery.Wit is the hallmark of Pride and Prejudice and a talent completely alien to Ms. Sittenfeld. Instead of pages peppered with sardonic quips and epigrams we are anesthetized with the endless drones and whines of petty malcontents. Mr. Collins, Lady Catherine de Bourgh and Mrs. Bennett are three of the great comic creations of literature. Each serves an important function, allowing Austen to gently satirize figures of power, i.e., the Church, the aristocracy, parental 'authority'. Those reincarnated in Eligible are barely recognizable boobies who are merely contemptible.Worse yet are Eligible's two eldest daughters, Elizabeth and Jane. The original Elizabeth Bennett is a woman of intelligence, humor and the courage to stand up for her sex and what one might term an equality of the talented. She is a model of moral rectitude and propriety and as the daughter of a gentleman, she is, therefore, a lady. Her place in the world is determined by not merely her birth but by her behavior. The modern Ms. Bennett is unremarkable in every way except she is a bit of a skank, having an affair with a married man, injudicious in personal relationships and rather stuck in the same mid-level job for years and going nowhere. The problem with depicting Ms.
I love Jane Austen, but I’m not a rabid purist. I’ve enjoyed plenty of follow-ons to her various novels and I like lots of the different film and TV dramatizations. I was a little dubious about the announcement of The Austen Project, in which six contemporary authors would reimagine the Austen novels in the present day. So much of Austen depends on the exploration of the social conventions and class structure of its time, none of which can be readily translated to the modern day. But I like Curtis Sittenfeld’s work, so I thought Eligible would be worth reading.What a disappointment. There was little charm, romance or erotic tension in this too-modern retelling. The characters lack the nuance of Austen’s versions and are mostly just flat-out dislikable. Not Jane and Elizabeth, but neither are they the kind of warm or, in Elizabeth’s case, good-naturedly impertinent characters that Austen made them.The biggest problem for me is the sex. By making the eldest daughters nearing 40, it goes without saying that they will be sexually active. But Sittenfeld spends too much time on sexual situations and they’re not romantic or erotic. Here’s the worst, though:*******************SPOILER*****************Instead of having romantic/erotic tension between Elizabeth and Darcy, Sittenfeld has them go straight from animosity to “hate sex.” I just about threw the book across the room with that.*****************END SPOILER**************Though the sex issue was a big problem for me, it was just one of several aspects of Sittenfeld’s modernization that fell flat. Her Cousin William Collins is just as boring and inexplicably self-satisfied as Austen’s, but now, instead of being a clergyman, he’s a dot-com multi-millionaire.
Eligible: A modern retelling of Pride and Prejudice Pride and Prejudice: Keira Knightley starring [PRIDE AND PREJUDICE] [10, 6 wol Unicode secondary events] (Korean edition) (2010) Pride and Prejudice and Zombies (Movie Tie-in Edition) (Pride and Prej. and Zombies) Pride and Prejudice and Zombies: Now with Ultraviolent Zombie Mayhem! Pride and Prejudice and Zombies: Dawn of the Dreadfuls Pride and Prejudice and Zombies (Quirk Classic Series) Pride and Prejudice (Fourth Edition) (Norton Critical Editions) Pride and Prejudice Pride and Prejudice (Adaptation): Oxford Bookworms Library, Stage 6 Pride and Prejudice [Blackstone Audio] Pride and Prejudice: Music from the Motion Picture Soundtrack (Easy Piano) Pride and Prejudice: Dramatisation Jane Austen Unabridged CD Collection: Pride and Prejudice, Persuasion, Emma Pride and Prejudice Audio CD Set (3 CDs) (Cambridge Literature) Pride and Prejudice (Unabridged Classics in Audio) Pride and Prejudice (Penguin Classics) Pride and Prejudice (The Classic Collection) Pride and Prejudice (Talking Classics) Pride And Prejudice (cd) (Penguin Classics) Pride and Prejudice Audiobook Cd Set