Audio CD
Publisher: Stone Vista Media (April 30, 2008)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0981625045
ISBN-13: 978-0981625041
Product Dimensions: 6 x 5.5 x 1 inches
Shipping Weight: 9.6 ounces
Average Customer Review: 4.4 out of 5 stars See all reviews (178 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #1,651,740 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #71 in Books > Books on CD > Parenting & Families > Parenting #17296 in Books > Parenting & Relationships > Parenting
Now that my kids are 13 and 15, and I've referred to the positive parenting books and other approaches for raising kids many times, I wanted to give a review looking back on what's been helpful so far and what hasn't. In short, I agree with the reviewer who said check it out of the library but don't buy it. The good stuff: much of the advice about developing a loving relationship with your kids as the foundation of discipline, listening to them, involving them in decision-making, creating a sense of belonging in the family, avoiding making kids feel bad just to gain temporary control all is good advice. So it's useful to be reminded of these things periodically. The bad stuff: the positive parenting books promote this overzealously, like this is the one and only approach that will always work and any other attempts at discipline, including any negative consequences that parents impose, are bad. Also the books strongly imply that pretty much any misbehavior by kids always comes from lacking a sense of belonging in the home or "discouragement." That is sometimes true, but is an oversimplification. Sometimes your kid doesn't want to brush his teeth because it's basically a boring chore and he'd rather be playing, not because you've failed to create a sense of belonging in the home. And because the ideas in this book about the roots of misbehavior are sometimes off, a lot of the examples are unrealistic, too. Many of them read like: Johnny is hitting his little brother and taking away his toys. Parents give him a positive time-in, explore his sense of discouragement, help him see he could play with his own toys as a positive alternative. Johnny says with a twinkle in his eye "oh right!" and doesn't hit his little brother any more. Yeah, well.....
If you are a parent, this book should definitely be on your list of MUST-READs. The idea focuses on respect, letting kids have control over some of their decisions, letting them experience the consequences -- both good and bad -- and reducing conflict in your home. The book helped me see the problems in some of the traditional methods of "discipline" I had been using, and it changed my approach for dealing with two-year old son and our interactions. The book includes concrete examples and focus areas for positive discipline, and explores the long range goals for raising our kids (like what kind of people we want them to be in the end). Since I've started putting the positive discipline principles into practice, I've seen an incredible difference in myself and my son. I started asking for his help, and now he is doing all sorts of things for himself -- getting dressed, helping carry in groceries, and willingly climbing into his car seat (if you can belive it)!! He's so excited to be making contributions to our family on his own, and I'm enjoying him so much without so many tantrums. I've been teaching him about respect -- it sounds so silly, but he seems to understand that it's about treating each other like we like each other. Of course, it isn't the end of every conflict and we still have problems and short tempers sometimes, but it is over so much faster and with fewer hurt feelings on all sides. We're finding a nice balance -- not permissive, not authoritarian -- just respectful and fair. Even if you don't accept the premise of the book, I think it will challenge you to evaluate your own parenting methods.
Positive Discipline (Audio Book) Positive Discipline Workshop 5 CD Set: An audio workshop with Jane Nelsen Master Self-Discipline: Simple and Effective Steps to Develop Self Discipline, Get Organized, and Make Things Happen! (Willpower, Stress Management, Self ... (Self Improvement And Motivational Book 1) Daily Self-Discipline: Everyday Habits and Exercises to Build Self-Discipline and Achieve Your Goals Positive Discipline for Single Parents : Nurturing, Cooperation, Respect and Joy in Your Single-Parent Family Positive Discipline Birth to Five Positive Discipline (MP3 CD) I Am Positive: 31 Positive Affirmations For A Prosperous Soul (Negative Self Talk Book 4) Positive Options for Living with Lupus: Self-Help and Treatment (Positive Options for Health) Chicken Soup for the Soul: Think Positive: 101 Inspirational Stories about Counting Your Blessings and Having a Positive Attitude Summary: The Fifth Discipline: Review and Analysis of Senge's Book Introducing Architectural Theory: Debating a Discipline The Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of the Learning Organization No-Drama Discipline: The Whole-Brain Way to Calm the Chaos and Nurture Your Child's Developing Mind No Bad Kids: Toddler Discipline Without Shame Organize and Create Discipline: An A-to-Z Guide to an Organized Existence Smart Love: The Compassionate Alternative to Discipline That Will Make You a Better Parent and Your Child a Better Person Discipline Without Tears: How to Reduce Conflict and Establish Cooperation in the Classroom Building Classroom Discipline Building Classroom Discipline (10th Edition)