Audio CD
Publisher: Random House Audio; Abridged edition (September 27, 2005)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0739321846
ISBN-13: 978-0739321843
Product Dimensions: 4.9 x 1 x 5.7 inches
Shipping Weight: 6.4 ounces
Average Customer Review: 4.6 out of 5 stars See all reviews (581 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #1,032,866 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #101 in Books > Books on CD > Parenting & Families > Interpersonal Relations #1103 in Books > Books on CD > Nonfiction #1159 in Books > Books on CD > Health, Mind & Body > Personal Growth
I think Greg has great intentions with his book, but it's so similar to his first book, same set-up and style. Don't get me wrong, I think he does a great service esp for us women because we're too understanding, too nice, or whatever the case may be. I thought his first book was a God-send, but this one was kind of more of the same stuff. I don't discount his advice, but there's something missing; there's no positive focus on when it might be right to work it out or why it's important and healthy to want to talk things out. A person is not weak for wanting to understand "what happened." It's when someone goes overboard and won't let go, and I realize that is probably the emotional starting point for this book.I realize, from my own recent experience, that some people (not just men) can be present during the course of a breakup and there are those who simply check out and run away. Greg seems to focus on just that one type of person. And so I think his advice is on target when it comes to the emotionally spineless person who runs from a breakup; the kind who sends all kinds of mixed signals and then blindsides the person who is in love with them. It happened to me, and I understand the pain of that kind of breakup. I tried to talk to my boyfriend and he wouldn't see me or talk to me. It was the shock of my life; I never saw it coming, truly. If I have anything to pass on, it is important to hold yourself in as much dignity as possible; but don't beat yourself up if you email him or call; you're human and you are hurt and it is natural and healthy to want to understand what happened, esp if you never saw it coming.Again, I'm not discounting the advice Greg gives here; I just found it to be more of the same stuff from his first book.
I nearly gave this book four stars because it really does make you open your eyes and see your situation with greater clarity. When I started out reading this, my ex had just come sniffing around sending me mixed signals and I wanted to get back together. Spending a few hours with this book has made me open my eyes and realize I probably shouldn't. So yes, it has value. But like Behrendt's first foray into self help, HE'S JUST NOT THAT INTO YOU, it oversimplifies things and many of its help is really the same common sense your girlfriends have been trying to drill into your brain. Greg Behrendt is operating from the principle that whenever a man breaks up with a woman (and since this book is geared towards women, that is usually what we're working from) he absolutely has already emotionally disconnected from her, does not want to be with her, and doesn't want to get back together with her EVER. Honestly, from personal experience I have found this just isn't the case. Men (and women) have a variety of different reasons for breaking up with people, since we're all complicated creatures. And I've personally found that if you leave the guy who broke up with you alone and don't chase him he comes back on his own accord. Greg obviously doesn't have experience with this, while any woman will tell you that guys who break up with you always come back and usually you don't want them anymore. I'm also finding plenty of sweeping generalizations that are simply not true. For instance, Behrendt declared that men get over breakups faster than women do ALWAYS and that's just the way men are wired. (And he asserts this while telling how own war story of a descent into alcoholic unemployment over a break-up, no less)!
Before I review this book...I would like to get a major pet peeve off my chest. I read some of the reviews before I started writing this and came across a review where the person had not read the whole book yet wrote a review. I would like to say that a review is where you read the WHOLE BOOK and then criticize it all you like...not read it halfway through and feel that writing a review is credible. It is not. The point of a review is to offer up your point of view which is not possible if you haven't read the whole book.Now that I have said that...I thought this book was terrific. Whether you dislike Greg using the word Superfox or not...the book was insightful, funny, compassionate and didn't offer the same platitudes or psychobabble that one encounters in other books of this genre.Greg and Amiira did not write this book from some lofty ivory tower. They have been in the trenches like a lot uf us. Greg drank and chased after his ex until he finally saw the light at the end of a very long tunnel and got into AA.Amiira was married and while not as destructive as Greg...her pain, misery [and sleepless nights] are nearly as poignant as Greg's.I have read this book three times and found something new to hold on to each time I read it.Some of the elements I particularly liked in this book start with the questions to Greg and his answers...sometimes tart ["how about pretending not to be completey crazy" he says to one woman in the throes of...well..acting completely crazy] were always enlightening.I also enjoyed "The Best Worst News", and "What I Did Wrong" where Greg and Amiira share...what they did wrong.
It's Called a Breakup Because It's Broken: The Smart Girl's Break-Up Buddy Buddy: The Story of Buddy Holly Buddy Does Seattle: The Complete Buddy Bradley Stories from "Hate" Comics (1990-1994) (Vol. 1) (Hate) A Smart Girl's Guide: Cooking: How to Make Food for Your Friends, Your Family & Yourself (Smart Girl's Guides) A Smart Girl's Guide: Middle School (Revised): Everything You Need to Know About Juggling More Homework, More Teachers, and More Friends! (Smart Girl's Guides) A Smart Girl's Guide to Style (Smart Girl's Guides) A Smart Girl's Guide: Money (Revised): How to Make It, Save It, and Spend It (Smart Girl's Guides) A Smart Girl's Guide: Babysitting: The Care and Keeping of Kids (Smart Girl's Guides) A Smart Girl's Guide: Drama, Rumors & Secrets: Staying True to Yourself in Changing Times (Smart Girl's Guides) Have a Nice Life Asshole: Breakup Stress Reliever Adult Coloring Book Getting Past Your Breakup: How to Turn a Devastating Loss into the Best Thing That Ever Happened to You Broken Mirrors/Broken Minds: The Dark Dreams of Dario Argento Broken Windows, Broken Business: How the Smallest Remedies Reap the Biggest Rewards Because I Am a Girl: I can change the world A Smart Girl's Guide: Staying Home Alone (Revised): A Girl's Guide to Feeling Safe and Having Fun A Smart Girl's Guide to the Internet (American Girl (Quality)) Making Money: A How-To Book for A Smart Girl's Guide: Money (American Girl) Tour:Smart: And Break the Band A Girl Called Jack A Girl Called Problem